Home   Help Search Login Register  

Leona Lewis: Without You

Pages: [1] 2
  Print  
Author Topic: Leona Lewis: Without You  (Read 4323 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Leona Lewis: Without You
by Lisa on: December 02, 2006, 12:08:37 PM »

Lisa
(7031 posts)
Offline View Profile

I thought this was a slightly predictable song choice for Leona, though not a bad one. It is a difficult song to sing and Leona absolutely nailed it.

She is starting to gain confidence on stage which I think makes a big difference to her performance. Leona has yet to perform badly on the X Factor and she certainly didn't tonight. In fact she was note perfect!

The judges said:

Sharon Osbourne: "Just so beautifully sung....You sang from your soul Leona."

Louis Walsh:" I think you're going to be an absolute star. You're a natural."

Simon Cowell: "That was just an incredible performance Leona."
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by Trudy on: December 02, 2006, 12:24:22 PM »

Trudy
(24859 posts)
Offline View Profile

I thought it was lovely, if she does not get in the final its a fix.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by KylieC on: December 02, 2006, 04:27:38 PM »
KylieC
(25 posts)
Offline View Profile

Potentially my favourite song ever; loved it. She was amazing. Leona for X Factor!
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by Gerard on: December 02, 2006, 04:30:42 PM »

Gerard
(4535 posts)
Offline View Profile

Leona performed Without You perfectly. The girl needs a record deal, immediately!

Like Simon said weeks ago, she should have a deal already.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by Saz on: December 03, 2006, 09:34:31 AM »

Saz
(146 posts)
Offline View Profile

Please don't berate me for this, I'm just saying it as see it!   Grin

I don't think it was perfect as it sounded to me like she struggled with some of those lower notes.

I do think she did very well with this song overall if you're into that kind of music.  However, I'm really not a fan of this trilling, lip quivering thing that she does.  Plus I really loved Nilsson's version, hated Mariah Carey's and Leona, IMO, did a virtual copy of the later.

Sorry.  I know a lot of people really rate her, and I honestly do believe she has bags of talent and an amazing voice. She's just not my kinda thing.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by Trudy on: December 03, 2006, 11:30:57 AM »

Trudy
(24859 posts)
Offline View Profile

It just shows that everyone is different, I loved her performances, I also think Whitney Houston is good. I  did not rate Ben at all this week, even though he took risks as you say, I thought it was one of his worst evenings. But as I say if we all liked the same thing life would be boring.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by Saz on: December 03, 2006, 11:38:47 AM »

Saz
(146 posts)
Offline View Profile

Exactly Trudy. Smiley
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by aqualitystreet on: December 03, 2006, 12:53:43 PM »

aqualitystreet
(422 posts)
Offline View Profile

Well Saz i have to agree with you....i was willing her on when she was way down there with the low notes.

I like Leona very much and i'm sort of convinced she's going to win ,  i really don't like the lip quiver thingy either.....ooooer what's all that about? Can't she sing without doing it? Is it an "in thing"? to do Huh

I do think she has gained a bit of confidence over the last couple of weeks , she actually looks into the camera.....at last ....and also seems to be a little bit more relaxed.

And it would be really boring if we all liked the same thing....lets face it...there would be no competition would there? Roll Eyes

Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by AGEING TART on: December 04, 2006, 04:57:19 PM »

AGEING TART
(5356 posts)
Offline View Profile

I'm sorry but Harry Neilson's version of this song has got to be the best.

Leonna in my view gave a weak performance in the middle of her voice on the soft edge and at the bottom the notes didn't exist.

MAUREEN
AGEING TART
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by VoiceOf Reason on: December 06, 2006, 01:43:38 PM »
VoiceOf Reason
(119 posts)
Offline View Profile

As has been said elsewhere.

Her performances of 'Without you' and 'I will allways love you' belong on 'Stars in their eyes' not x-factor.

If she wants to keep her credibility shes need to get back to original arrangements ie 'Summertime' and 'Sorry'. She did manage it on the same night with 'Could it be magic' but everyone has completely overlooked that excellent performance and focused on 'Without you' which although technically perfect, had a negative affect on her reputation. IE people just comment 'Oh shes trying to copy MC.



Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by AGEING TART on: December 11, 2006, 04:07:12 PM »

AGEING TART
(5356 posts)
Offline View Profile

Well Saz i have to agree with you....i was willing her on when she was way down there with the low notes.

I like Leona very much and i'm sort of convinced she's going to win ,  i really don't like the lip quiver thingy either.....ooooer what's all that about? Can't she sing without doing it? Is it an "in thing"? to do Huh

I do think she has gained a bit of confidence over the last couple of weeks , she actually looks into the camera.....at last ....and also seems to be a little bit more relaxed.

And it would be really boring if we all liked the same thing....lets face it...there would be no competition would there? Roll Eyes



Hello aqualitystreet,

Lip quiver thingy...

There are several reasons why the lips will quiver

the first, due to an uneven flow of air and a wrongly placed note causes a nervous reaction in the lip muscle and nerves...

two, the voice is weak in a certain voice register maybe the notes aren't really there and the lips cannot help but quiver with vibrato at the effort....

three, an excess force of air and a wrongly placed note with vowel pushing on the lip muscle and nerve tickling it...

four, the number of notes and the flow of air is insufficient to finish the line of music, the voice consciously takes what it needs and divides the air up breaking the flow of sound thus resulting in lip quivering with a few notes to go with it not belonging to the key of the piece.

The latter I have noticed has been very popular with pop singers, jazz singers, blues singers and soul singers who seem to think it is the done thing to do.So much so if you were really listening the end of lines is often flat.

In classical music performers, all of the above would be regarded as a vocal fault, as all notes which are for singing must be what is printed. The bridge passages of runs or ornamentations for classical singers are all printed where the composer wants them and each note is allocated a time segment within the pace of the music. However, as a Mozart fan I enjoy listening to singers who often deviate from a printed Coda and improvise one of there own.

A singer who can sing Mozart, it used to be said could sing anything. Wink

MAUREEN
AGEING TART.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by VoiceOf Reason on: December 12, 2006, 03:46:32 AM »
VoiceOf Reason
(119 posts)
Offline View Profile

Maureen.

I have my own theory on the vibrato, Xtina Aguilara tends to do exactly the same.

You don't hear it as pronounced when they sing acoustically.

I think, on stage, with the huge delay and volume of the sound systems, the artists can not process the sound information in their heads quick enough to keep control of the note pitch.

In others words they are not sure that the note is pitched correctly with all the feedback going on and so the brain automatically varies the tone around the frequency so the note averages out correctly.

You don't notice this with some artists because they don't dwell on notes for long periods of time. Others have learnt to deal with it with experience.

Some keep it as part of their voice signature.

I must say, I do actually find it quite attractive, maybe I'm weird.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by quinnfan on: December 12, 2006, 09:38:03 AM »
quinnfan
(15 posts)
Offline View Profile

She has a good voice but we have heard that type of voice before and lets be honest.... she has  mucb personality a a damp teatowel!!! Bland as  boiled potato.
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by VoiceOf Reason on: December 12, 2006, 01:48:30 PM »
VoiceOf Reason
(119 posts)
Offline View Profile

But we have heard Rays voice a million times before in every pub we go in!

He has no personality worth mentioning either.

He reminds one of a vetriloquists dummy.

His quiff belongs in the 1950's

Robbie williams does swing 1,000,0000 times better

need I go on...
Logged
Re: Leona Lewis: Without You
by Trudy on: December 12, 2006, 03:26:08 PM »

Trudy
(24859 posts)
Offline View Profile

Perhaps there personalities will develop more as they get more confident, lets remember they are young, singing live to an audience which is more than some established acts do. At the moment they are so busy and focused on learning new songs each week and preparing themselves for the critisism of the judges there is not much chance of personalities shining through, give them both a chance.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Subscribe by RSS | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions of Use | Contact Us
Unless otherwise stated, all content of this site is copyright of Unrealitytv Limited, 2008 - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by SMF 1.1.11 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC